|Cutie Mark:||Three Horseshoes|
Toffee has brown hair and coat and blue eyes. Toffee's cutie mark is three blue horseshoes. Toffee appears to live in Appleloosa. Toffee also wears a tophat. She has a similar design to Caramel. Her other names are Caramella and Chell (a reference to the Portal series).
Toffee has only made one appearance throughout the whole My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic series, meaning her first appearance was her last appearance. Toffee made her debut appearance in Over a Barrel.